Shahrbanoo Sadat : “I have no message. Just come and watch my film !”
Shahrbanoo Sadat wants cinema from Afghanistan to break free from the familiar narratives of war, violence and poverty. Now living in Germany, she challenges the expectations placed on Afghanistan artists by European funding institutions and calls for the freedom to tell stories beyond suffering.
Shahrbanoo Sadat is 35 years old and lives in Germany. She is the director of the film « No Good Men, » which opens in our cinemas on November 25th.
She believes that Afghanistan cinema should not be limited to stories of war, violence, and poverty. In this interview, she discusses the identity crisis, the experience of migration, and the restrictions facing filmmakers from Afghanistan. She also criticises European film-funding institutions, which, in her view, often expect artists to tell stories exclusively about war and suffering.
Sadat calls for the freedom to choose subjects and genres, from romance and comedy to horror and science fiction. She also reflects on patriarchy, the state of cinema in Afghanistan following the Taliban’s return to power, and her hopes for the future of independent filmmaking.
« I started filmmaking without any formal academic training. »
You have been working in cinema for nearly 17 years and have made several short and feature films. I would first like to ask you about yourself and the journey that brought you into the world of cinema. What inspired you to use filmmaking as a way of telling stories about Afghanistan ?
« My parents are from Afghanistan, but I was born in Iran. When I was 11 years old, we came back to Afghanistan and lived in Bamiyan province. I have been working in cinema for about 17 years. I started filmmaking without any formal academic training, making short films and gradually learning the craft along the way.
I have struggled with an identity crisis throughout my life. In Iran, people saw me as Afghan; in Afghanistan, they saw me as Iranian. This is also a familiar experience for many migrant and displaced families who live with questions of belonging and their roots. Today, I am happy to be a filmmaker. It is a valuable opportunity for me, as a woman, to tell the history and stories of society in Afghanistan from a human and visual perspective and, rather than repeating stereotypes, to bring lesser-heard stories to the screen.
I made my first film about ten years ago. The story of its main character, Mr. Qudrat, begins when he arrives in Kabul at the age of six. The film ends at a point where he encounters another character. The story takes place in Kabul in 1989. In the film, Mr. Qudrat lives in an orphanage that was under Soviet government support at the time. The story follows his life in that environment and the events he experiences there, including how one of the characters goes to Russia. Gradually, the narrative moves towards the beginning of the Afghanistan civil war.
Mr. Qudrat grows up and becomes an adult. In fact, these films, taken together, follow one character’s life through different historical and social periods in Afghanistan. Of course, the films were not shot in Afghanistan. We worked in Tajikistan to make some of them, and the most recent film was made in Germany. »
Your portrayal of Afghanistan differs from the image usually presented in international media and some documentaries. Has your attempt to offer a different image of Afghanistan become a kind of challenge to the international community’s perspective ?
« Honestly, that’s their problem, not mine! I am happy to challenge these expectations, although I sometimes feel hurt and angry about how certain international institutions approach films like mine. When I was seeking funding, some major European film foundations sent me letters explicitly stating that they would not support my project because it was not the kind of film they considered appropriate.
Those same institutions spoke about brave women from Afghanistan taking to the streets of Kabul to fight patriarchy. I thought: what are you talking about ? Am I not one of those women ? I am a woman from Afghanistan trying to make films and tell my own stories, yet you are standing in my way ! How dare you tell an Afghan artist who has lived in the country, experienced its realities, been evacuated from her homeland, and is now trying to express her trauma through cinema what kind of films she is allowed to make ? This attitude is humiliating and deeply patronising.
« I want to see the day when an Afghan filmmaker can choose to make science fiction, horror, thrillers, or comedy. »
I hope to open doors for other filmmakers from Afghanistan. I want to see the day when an Afghan filmmaker can choose to make science fiction, horror, thrillers, or comedy without European institutions insisting that they should only make films about war. Why must Afghan stories always be confined to suffering and destruction? For me, cinema is not simply a business. It is connected to my identity, my country, my people, and my historical and psychological wounds. Sometimes I feel like a bridge connecting stories that have never been heard.
I have been fortunate to survive, learn English, and gain access to filmmaking. Now, I refuse to censor myself or compromise with other people’s expectations. Many institutions do not understand our realities, while some filmmakers unconsciously reproduce the image the Western world expects of them. I can no longer accept that. »

In one of your previous interviews, you spoke about your film « No Man Is a Good Man » and your perspective on its male characters. Do you believe that men in Afghanistan are also victims of the patriarchal system ?
« Yes, I genuinely believe men are also victims of this system, although I say this carefully. Until my early twenties, I was a very angry young woman. I saw injustice everywhere, from my own home and my father’s behaviour to the men around me. I was convinced I should never marry or have children. I wanted to be an independent, working woman because I believed that any relationship with a man would destroy my life. In my mind, men represented harm and destruction.
Today, I understand that younger version of myself and feel empathy for her. I am grateful to be a filmmaker because cinema teaches me empathy every day. It has taught me that there are no entirely good or bad characters. We are human beings, shaped by our circumstances, all trying to survive, be seen, valued, and heard. »
In your film, there is a man who is married and cheats on his wife. Through this character, were you trying to explore the idea that men are also victims of the patriarchal system ?
« For me, this is not about moral judgment. I don’t want to label a character as good or bad; I want the audience to understand his circumstances. Many men in Afghanistan marry in their early twenties, often through arranged marriages, and by the age of 30 may have seven or eight children and be their family’s sole breadwinner. Society expects them to provide for everyone.
« I see my film’s male character, to a large extent, as a victim of the patriarchal system he lives in. »
Now imagine a man in his forties or fifties, carrying all these responsibilities, who suddenly falls in love with someone else. How can he express his feelings when even sharing them with a friend might lead to judgment ? Love is, above all, a human emotion. Persian literature often presents stereotypical, male-centred narratives of love, overlooking its complexity. I want to explore these human contradictions. That is why I see my film’s male character, to a large extent, as a victim of the patriarchal system he lives in. »
Do you think society, and even international institutions, also play a role in reproducing these structures ?
« Absolutely. Many people don’t even realise what kind of system they are accepting and perpetuating. In my opinion, one of the biggest mistakes of the past twenty years was that many NGOs, international organisations, and funding institutions focused too heavily on women’s issues, even though, in many cases, they were not genuinely concerned about women’s rights at all. There was also a great deal of corruption in this field.
« Feminism cannot move forward without men. I believe women and men must move forward together. »
But the more important issue is that they made many men believe that women’s issues were exclusively women’s concerns. Feminism cannot move forward without men. I believe women and men must move forward together. Feminism is about creating a world in which all human beings are equal and respect one another. Men are part of that world too. »
Your film initially has a romantic, and sometimes even comedic atmosphere, but towards the end it becomes quite tragic and melancholic. Given the Taliban’s return to power and the collapse of the Afghanistan Republic, why did you decide to set the story during that particular period ?
« At first, I simply wanted to make a love story set in contemporary Kabul. I was living in Kabul in 2019 and 2020. But about a year later, the situation in the country changed completely, and I was displaced too. That is why I decided to set my love story during the Republic era, a period I had personally witnessed and lived through. My memories of that time were still fresh, and I could recreate the atmosphere and circumstances in detail. I wanted the film to serve, in a way, as a document and a reminder for the future, so that nobody would portray that period in an unrealistic or idealised way or imagine that everything was perfect for everyone in Afghanistan at the time. »
Did you film any parts of the movie in Afghanistan? Even the scenes that appear to take place in Kabul, for example, on St. Valentine’s Day ?
« No, the entire film was shot in Germany, in Berlin and Hamburg. Even the scenes that appear to take place in Afghanistan were recreated in Hamburg. We worked with members of the Afghan community there, and the experience was very well received. We also incorporated archival footage filmed by actual cinematographers in Afghanistan, combining it with the images we shot for the film. »
Given the current situation in Afghanistan and the Taliban’s return to power, how do you see the future of cinema and filmmaking in the country? A young generation of Afghans is growing up today without free access to cinema or proper filmmaking facilities. Are you optimistic about the future of the cinema ?
« Since the Taliban returned to power, many people have turned to creating content on YouTube, TikTok, and other social media platforms. But these activities cannot replace real cinema and feature films. The truth is that even during the Republic era, my professional circumstances were not that different. I used to travel to Tajikistan to make my films, recreate villages and locations, and bring actors from Afghanistan. For my most recent project, I cast actors in Germany, and the funding for my films has always come from outside Afghanistan. So, professionally speaking, not much has changed for me.
« I don’t want to keep making dramas. My dream for my next film is to make a science-fiction movie. »
Nevertheless, I am very optimistic about the future of independent Afghan cinema. We have made remarkable progress in documentary filmmaking, but fiction films and feature-length productions still require significantly more financial resources. This cinema does not necessarily have to be made inside Afghanistan. Filmmakers, whether they live in the country or abroad, are still part of Afghan cinema. Perhaps we don’t have a large audience today, but that doesn’t mean our cinema has come to an end. We continue to create and make films with whatever resources are available to us. »
What are your plans for your next project? What kinds of films would you like to make in the future ?
« I want to break free from restrictive frameworks. In European cinema, Afghanistan filmmakers are often expected to settle for small budgets and limited resources, working with small crews to make films that are predominantly social dramas or war stories. I disagree with this approach. I don’t want to keep making dramas. My dream for my next film is to make a science-fiction movie.
« Why shouldn’t a filmmaker from Afghanistan be able to dream beyond these boundaries ? »
I am tired of repeating stereotypical narratives about Afghanistan. I want to tell stories through a variety of genres, including comedy, thrillers, horror, and science fiction, and reach a wider international audience. Why shouldn’t a filmmaker from Afghanistan be able to dream beyond these boundaries ? »
Finally, if you could leave a message for your audience, particularly international audiences, what would you say ?
« I don’t have a message ! [She laughs] Just come and watch my film ! »
Shahrbanoo Sadat’s « No Good Men » returns to the big screen on 30 November at cinema Vendome in Brussels.
Organised in collaboration with Amnesty International, the Network of Afghan Diaspora Organizations in Europe (NADOE), and O’Brother, the screening will be followed by a debate.
📍 Cinema Vendome, Brussels
📅 30 November
🕡 18:30




